I added money to my Venmo account and still couldn't get my order
- about billing
Captured on . See reviews on Google Play
VenmoReported repeatedly
People cannot reach their own money when a transfer fails
6 people raised this, on both iOS and Android.
Android and iPhone users in the United States, across two app versions.
In their own words
Neither app store gives a review a permanent public link, so each entry is a snapshot taken on the date shown and the link goes to the app's review listing.
A deposit was made to my account a week ago today.
- said they were leaving
- about billing
Captured on . See reviews on the App Store
Have not been able to send a single payment. It just gives me an error message that says it can't be completed at this time.
- about billing
Captured on . See reviews on Google Play
I can't pay someone I have paid in the past.
- about billing
- worked before an update
Captured on . See reviews on Google Play
I can't actually access this page because I keep getting an error every time I try to access it
- about billing
- worked before an update
Captured on . See reviews on the App Store
It won't just come back into my Venmo like it's supposed to
- about billing
Captured on . See reviews on Google Play
What people do instead
Nobody described a way around this.
What you could do with this
These four are written from the reviews above. Everything else on this page is quoted or counted.
written
BUILD IT
An error that names which step failed and what happens next.
See how3 points
- Distinguish the network, the bank and the account state in the message
- Say whether the money moved, is held, or never left
- Start with the repeat-payee failure reviewers describe
Why it might not workPayment failures often originate at the bank, and the app is contractually limited in what it may disclose.
written
START IT
A status layer for transfers that are neither sent nor returned.
See how2 points
- Shows where a transfer actually sits between institutions
- Aimed at people paid irregularly, who notice immediately
Why it might not workThe institutions holding that state do not expose it, which is the reason the gap exists.
written
STUDY IT
What do people do in the hour after a payment fails?
See how2 points
- Track reported next actions: retry, switch app, contact the bank
- Separate failures where money moved from failures where it did not
Why it might not workFinancial behaviour is sensitive and people under-report the amounts involved.
written
WRITE IT
The error message that means nothing and holds your money.
See how2 points
- Follow one failed transfer through every party that touched it
- Quote the reviews where the same payee worked last week
Why it might not workOutage coverage exists; the specific story is the message rather than the outage.
Related challenges
Strava
People lose the activity they were in the middle of recording
the program keeps stopping in the middle of my hike
Build itA recorder that writes each location fix to disk as it arrives.
Start itA recorder whose only job is not to stop.
Study itHow often does a consumer tracker lose part of a session?
Write itThe run that did not happen because the app stopped.
Reported repeatedly
Duolingo
People lose a daily streak when the lesson will not load
it also won't load kana or other character / writing lessons
Build itA lesson that is fully on the device before it starts.
Start itOffline-first practice for people with unreliable connections.
Study itDoes an outage break a learning habit, or only pause it?
Write itGamified learning that punishes you for its own outage.
Reported repeatedly
Airbnb
People are stopped by errors that explain nothing at all
Uninstalled the app and reinstalled, no luck!
Build itAn error that names the step, the cause and the retry.
Start itError-message review as a service for product teams.
Study itWhat does a generic error cost in abandoned actions?
Write itThe error message as a design decision, not an accident.
Reported repeatedly